Listening Notes - Suno vs ACE 1.5 (2026-08-17)

17 Aug 2026

Listening Notes - Suno vs ACE 1.5 (2026-08-17)

Track: "The Hand That Stays Out"

Objective Measurements

|--------|------|---------| | Duration | 3:05 (184.6s) | 3:22 (202.0s) | | Integrated loudness | -13.5 LUFS | -14.5 LUFS | | True peak | -0.7 dBTP | -1.2 dBTP | | Loudness range (LRA) | 6.1 LU | 5.3 LU | | Overall RMS | -15.2 dB | -16.1 dB | | Peak | -0.7 dB | -1.3 dB |

Section-by-Section RMS (10s windows)

|------|----------|------------|-------| | 0s | -19.5 | -19.8 | Both start quiet - intro/verse 1 | | 10s | -18.0 | -17.7 | Both rising - verse 1 continues | | 40s | -16.8 | -17.2 | Verse 1 → chorus 1 transition | | 60s | -15.6 | -16.1 | | | 80s | -16.3 | -16.1 | | | 90s | -15.9 | -19.5 | ACE drops - possible verse 2 / quieter section | | 150s | -14.3 | -14.1 | Both in outro range | | 160s | -15.8 | -14.7 | ACE slightly louder (outro continuation) | | 180s | - | -14.8 | ACE only (longer track) | | 190s | - | -18.5 | ACE final fade |

Key Observations

ACE 1.5 track:

Gemma4:e2b Listening (verse/clip section)

ACE 1.5 (55-85s clip):

Comparison Summary

1. Both tracks are in the same genre - folk/singer-songwriter with acoustic guitar and intimate vocal. The composition translated well to both renderers.

3. ACE is more consistent - less variation between sections, gentler transitions. This could be a strength (consistency) or a weakness (less emotional impact from the breathturn).

4. ACE is longer - 17 seconds longer. Either the tempo is slightly slower or sections are extended. This needs investigation.

5. ACE has no Dakota voice - the vocal is present but generic. Once we train the voice model, this becomes the differentiator.

Next Steps

Open the full The Hand That Stays Out study

Conversation

Loading the conversation…

Back to studies